Is High Mileage a Deal-Breaker? Why Service History is More Important than the Odometer.

It’s the first question nearly every used car buyer asks: "What's the mileage?" For decades, we've been taught that a low number on the odometer is the ultimate sign of a good car. But what if I told you that this is one of the biggest and most costly myths in the motor trade?

As a professional car sourcer, I can tell you with absolute certainty: I would rather have a car with 100,000 miles and a perfect, documented history than a car with 40,000 miles and a history of neglect.

Understanding this single, counter-intuitive idea is the key to finding a truly reliable vehicle and getting the best possible value for your money. Let's break down why the service book is far more important than the odometer.

The Problem with "Low Mileage"

A low mileage figure looks great on paper, but it tells you nothing about how those miles were driven. A car used exclusively for short, stop-start journeys (like the classic "school run car") can suffer from significant mechanical wear.

These short trips don't allow the engine and exhaust systems to get up to full operating temperature, which can lead to:

• Carbon build-up in the engine.

• Premature wear on the clutch and brakes.

• Clogged DPF filters on diesel cars, a notoriously expensive repair.

• A battery that is constantly being drained and never fully recharged.

A car that has covered 90,000 miles cruising effortlessly on the motorway has often had a much easier life than a 40,000-mile city car.

The Power of a Perfect Service History

A car's service history is its medical record. It tells the true story of how it has been cared for. A great service history isn't just a book full of stamps; it's a folder full of invoices and receipts that prove the right work was done at the right time.

What I look for as an expert:

• Regular Servicing: Has the oil been changed on time, every time? This is the lifeblood of an engine.

• Major Interval Work: Has the cambelt and water pump been replaced at the manufacturer's recommended interval? This is a non-negotiable, multi-hundred-pound job that many neglect.

• Quality Parts: Do the invoices show that premium parts and the correct specification of oil were used?

• Reputable Garages: Was the work done by a main dealer or a respected independent specialist?

A car with a history like this has been owned by someone who cared, and that is the single best indicator of a reliable used car.

The Head-to-Head: Which Car Would You Choose?

Let's look at two identical cars, both for sale at £10,000.

Feature	Car A	Car B
Mileage	45,000 miles	95,000 miles
Service History	Missed two services, no invoice for cambelt change.	Full main dealer history, invoice for cambelt change last year.
Tyres	Mismatched budget brands.	Four matching premium-brand tyres.
Verdict	A ticking financial time bomb. Likely needs an immediate major service and a cambelt change (£800+). The budget tyres suggest a history of cutting corners.	A smart, de-risked purchase. The higher mileage is irrelevant because the crucial, expensive maintenance has been done. This car has been cherished.

The Car Compass Approach: Looking Beyond the Obvious

Anyone can read an odometer. My job is to read the car.

My 250-point inspection is designed to verify the story the paperwork tells. I scrutinise the service history, check for the quality of past repairs, and use my expertise to assess the true mechanical health of the vehicle.

This allows us to find incredible value in well-maintained, higher-mileage vehicles that other buyers might overlook, saving you money while getting you a more reliable car. We don't just find a car with the right numbers; we find the right car, full stop.

If you're ready to buy a car based on expert analysis, not just a number on the dashboard, get in touch for a free, no-obligation consultation.

Get Started Today